gentiles on this website: “The Old Testament God is cruel and vengeful!”
actual Jews in my synagogue yesterday: “My favorite part of the reading is when it says the Torah is not in heaven so it’s too far to reach, it’s not across the sea so we can’t get it, but that it’s in our hearts… the idea of having that be so close, of being so close to something divine, that thrills me.”
“And here, where it says ‘the Lord will delight in you as he did in your fathers’, that’s such a beautiful thing. You know, God is this all-powering being, and God delights in us.”gentiles on this website: “You can’t be an atheist and religious!”
actual Jews in my synagogue yesterday: “I’m just not buying any of this. I was born during the Holocaust and I could never wrap my mind around this omnipotent all-seeing God, and usually I’m a little moved by this, I try to be hopeful, but when I look around the world now, I just don’t buy it! If I really believed there was a God, I would resent him.” [still wears a prayer shawl and attends synagogue regularly]gentiles on this website: “Religious people never question what they’re told, they just followed blindly!”
my actual rabbi: “Sometimes the Torah can be like an older relative whom we love dearly, and who has a lot of wisdom to give, but who also says things that cause us pain, that we find offensive or wrong. And I think the wrong instinct would be to pretend we don’t hear what they’re saying, or to cut them out entirely, or to be guided by them into thinking and behaving in offensive ways. What we need to do is engage the Torah. We need to wrestle with it, and try to understand it, to figure out where it’s coming from and learn how we can progress from it, because the Torah is not unchanging. It belongs in each of our hearts, and it changes for us as we study it, as each generation challenges its old assumptions.”They actually have a name for that second thing, its called being agnostic you sassy fuck
You’ve never met a Jewish atheist, have you
“There is only one God…. and we DON’T believe in him!”
Even to believe or not believe is too xtian-atheist in style. It’s much more Jewish not to be sure of anything, certainty is a bit… erm religious…
Someone could be Chief Rabbi of the British Isles and explore doubt as part and parcel of their religious duty. To argue with G-D while question His and their own existence.
Judaism isn’t so narrow as to be just another religion, or just another race or just another culture, it flows seamlessly between all and Jews can exist in several points in that spectrum at once.In some religions ‘believing’, or at least towing the party line, is the condition of your membership. Where as, being and doing is more integral to Judaism. Someone could even reject religion entirely and raise their kids secular and still attend Yom Kippur, or not, and three generations later their descendants may still be fully Jewish and be in a position to return to observance with no holes barred to them. Imagine that level of religious freedom, you can have a ‘phase’ of a-thesim that lasts five decades and have lost not part of your place in Judaism.
As soon as you try and make Jewish theory fit goyish politics, religion, race or culture, you’ve fallen short of understanding what a Jew is.